Getting your app listed in the Shopify App Store is a significant opportunity for agencies looking to build recurring revenue streams. But standing out requires more than just good code – you need a strategic approach to both development and presentation.

Understanding what it takes to get approved

Before you start building, you need to understand Shopify's requirements. Your app needs to meet specific performance standards, including load time requirements and API usage limits. Security is also crucial – you'll need proper authentication handling and data protection measures in place.

Beyond the technical requirements, Shopify expects excellent documentation, reliable support, and clear communication with merchants. Many apps get rejected for issues that could have been avoided with proper preparation, like poor performance, security concerns, or inadequate support documentation.

‍

Getting your app ready for submission

Start by ensuring your app meets all technical requirements. This means thorough testing of:

Authentication flows: Your app must properly handle OAuth and session tokens for both embedded admin and storefront interactions. This includes managing token refresh and properly handling authentication errors.

API usage and rate limiting: Shopify strictly enforces a 2 requests per second API rate limit. You need robust retry logic and request queuing to handle this limitation gracefully.

Performance metrics: Your app needs to maintain fast load times, especially for buyer-facing components. Shopify requires checkout components to load within 5ms and embedded admin interfaces to achieve an LCP score under 2.5 seconds.

Security measures: Proper validation for webhooks is essential, as is setting appropriate security headers to prevent clickjacking. You'll also need to ensure you're not using third-party cookies in embedded apps.

Error handling: Your app should gracefully handle common failure scenarios like API timeouts or validation errors. Clear error messages and fallback behaviors are crucial for a good merchant experience.

You'll also need to set up your support system and create comprehensive documentation before submitting. Consider how you'll handle merchant questions, feature requests, and technical issues. Having these systems in place before submission will speed up the approval process.

‍

Making your listing stand out

Your app store listing is often a merchant's first impression of your app. The key elements that influence visibility and conversion are:

Your app title needs to be unique and distinctive - Shopify no longer accepts generic descriptive names like "Product Reviews" or "Blog Manager." Choose a brand name that sets your app apart and helps merchants remember it. Your app's functionality should be explained in the subtitle and description instead of stuffed into the name itself. 

Screenshots and videos need to show your app in action. Focus on key features and benefits rather than trying to show everything. Make sure these visuals are high quality and follow Shopify's guidelines for dimensions and content.

Your app description should lead with the most important information. Merchants often skim, so make your value proposition clear immediately. Use simple, direct language and break up text for readability.

If your app has a storefront component, you should set up a demo store that allows merchants to see what your app looks like when it's in use. Even if your app only touches a specific part of the storefront experience, make sure to spend some time making the rest of the test store look legitimate. Even if you think it's clear where to go and what to do to experience how your app works, merchants may not know, so be sure to provide them with clear instructions. If they've come this far, you don't want to lose them.

‍

Building social proof

Reviews and ratings significantly impact your app's visibility and credibility. However, don't fall into the trap of soliciting reviews too aggressively – this can backfire. Instead, focus on providing excellent service and making it easy for satisfied customers to share their experiences.

Consider developing case studies that demonstrate real results. These are particularly valuable for higher-priced apps or those targeting specific merchant segments.

‍

Maintaining momentum after launch

Getting approved is just the beginning. The Shopify App Store is a busy space, and you’ll need to consistently stay up to date in order to stay relevant.

Monitoring performance metrics allows you to identify and address issues quickly. Pay attention to installation rates, usage patterns, and uninstall reasons. Build analytics into your app from the start so you can identify potential problems before they affect too many merchants. Watch for patterns in support requests – they often signal areas that need improvement or better documentation.

Gathering and acting on merchant feedback will help guide your development roadmap. The most successful apps evolve based on user needs. Set up regular check-ins with your most active users and pay close attention to feature requests. Sometimes the smallest improvements can have the biggest impact on merchant satisfaction. Consider building a public roadmap to keep merchants engaged and informed about upcoming features.

Keeping your app updated and compatible with Shopify's latest API versions is essential. Shopify releases API updates quarterly, and staying current is crucial for long-term success and merchant retention. API versions older than a year quickly , so plan for these updates in your development cycle and make sure you have processes in place to test thoroughly before each release. Many apps lose functionality simply because they fall behind on API versions.

Once your app is established, aim for the Built for Shopify badge. This certification signals to merchants that your app meets Shopify's highest standards for performance, reliability, and support. Key requirements include maintaining an average LCP score under 2.5 seconds, providing excellent merchant support, and ensuring your app stays compatible with Shopify's latest features and API versions. The badge can significantly boost your app's visibility and credibility in the app store.

‍

Marketing beyond the app store

While app store optimization is important, don't rely solely on organic discovery. Consider creating content that helps merchants understand how to solve their problems using your app. This could include blog posts, video tutorials, or integration guides that show real solutions to common merchant challenges.

Understanding where your target merchants spend their time is crucial for effective marketing. Shopify merchants often gather in specific communities depending on their size and industry. Larger Plus merchants might be active in enterprise ecommerce forums, while smaller merchants might be more engaged on platforms like Reddit's r/shopify or Twitter. Some verticals, like fashion or beauty, have their own active Discord communities. Identifying these channels helps you participate in relevant conversations and share your expertise where it matters most.

If you're considering app store advertising, start small and measure results carefully. Focus on keywords and merchant segments where you've already seen organic success. Monitor which search terms lead to actual installations rather than just clicks. App store ads can be effective, but they need to be part of a broader marketing strategy rather than your only source of new users.

Partnering with other agencies or other app developers whose products complement yours is a common tactic in the Shopify ecosystem. Many merchants rely on your agency recommendations when choosing apps, and having your solution echoed by other trusted partners can be more effective than traditional advertising. Just make sure any partnerships genuinely benefit merchants rather than just driving installations.

The best marketing often comes from solving real problems exceptionally well. When merchants find genuine value in your app, they become natural advocates within their communities. Focus on building features that merchants want to talk about, and make it easy for them to share their success stories.

‍

Building for the long term

The most successful agencies in the Shopify ecosystem take a long-term view of their app store presence.

Make sure you maintain consistent quality and reliability even as you scale. Growth shouldn't come at the expense of existing users. As your user base grows, you'll need to balance adding new features with maintaining core functionality. Pay special attention to performance during high-traffic periods like BFCM, when many merchants experience their highest sales volumes. A stable, reliable app during these crucial times can lead to long-term merchant loyalty.

Build relationships within the Shopify ecosystem. Connect with other developers and agencies to stay informed about platform changes and opportunities. Join developer communities, participate in Shopify's partner events, and share your experiences. The ecosystem is constantly evolving, and staying connected helps you anticipate changes and adapt more quickly. When Shopify announces new features or deprecations, you'll want to be among the first to understand how these changes affect your app.

Continuously improve your app based on real merchant needs rather than just adding features for the sake of it. This might mean saying no to feature requests that could bloat your app or compromise its core functionality. Focus on solving specific problems well rather than trying to be everything to everyone. The most successful apps often do one thing exceptionally well rather than many things adequately.

Planning for scale also means thinking about your support infrastructure. As your user base grows, you'll need systems and processes that can grow with it. Consider how you'll handle increased support volume, feature requests, and bug reports. Many apps struggle not because of technical issues, but because they can't maintain quality support as they scale.

‍

Want to build a suite of low-maintenance, high-performance apps without spending days (or worse, weeks) on setup and Shopify OAuth? Gadget gives you a framework and infrastructure to build your app on a platform designed for Shopify development — and it’s free to start. 

Join our Discord community to connect with other developers and agencies building for the Shopify App Store!